Original PJ’s Pizza | Best Pizza in West Virginia

Most Popular

Try our most popular items.

Pepperoni Sub (12")

$11.00

Antipasto Salad (Regular)

$11.00

Italian Wedgie (Large)

$13.00

Wings (10 Pieces)

$14.00

PJs Special Pizza-

$8.00

Cheeseburger Pizza-

$8.00

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Locations

Some Things Happy Customers Have Said

If I could give it a 10 outta 10 I would. Food was amazing. Only thing I wish was different was if I had some more lol. Highly recommend

Zachary L.

PJ's Pizza , tasty in all three dimensions. 🤯🌌 Hear me out, get the PJ's special, hit it with some extra shake, maybe add some mushrooms and some black olives. Chef's kiss 😘, perfecto fam. Parking: Small to medium parking area, only fits probably 4-8 vehicles at once.

Clay H.

Very nice Pizza 🍕 good and hot plenty of cheese 🧀 dough was perfect very clean on inside counter lady was very respectful of course I'm going back love it ths u for great service 💞💞

Peggy G.

I have been getting pizza here for years. I have never had a bad experience. The wait can be a bit long at times but that's only because of the amount of business they do. Great pizza. Friendly staff. Love it!

Matthew W.

Pj’s Pizza, local favorite! One of my favorites for lunch in New Martinsville. The “kickin chicken” (buffalo chicken) is my favorite pizza. The subs and pepperoni buns are also awesome! The service is fairly fast and very friendly. Parking can be a little tricky but the location, right off the highway, is very easy to get to. Definitely recommend it!

Will G.

P J pizza is the best pizza I've had since in the past 38 yrs. I can remember as a child growing up we didn't have a whole lot of money so ordering take out was a luxury. When we did order out and my parents would get us P. J. Pizza. It was like having my birthday all over ahain

Becky K.

Featuring

Healthy Options

Gluten-Free Options

Easy Parking

A Culinary Landmark

Jack and Pat Welch found The Original PJs Pizza in 1969, and it becomes the first carryout-style pizza and sandwich shop in New Martinsville at the 495 Third Street location. And it’s still there – talk about a culinary landmark and a staple to the community.

Fresh Pizza for everyone!

Our Traditional and Gluten-Free Pizzas are the most delicious way to avoid making dinner. Fresh-cut vegetables, cheeses, and meats are made to order. Mouthwatering choices like the Meatzilla, Veggie Love, Pepperoni, PJ's Special, and Works will keep you coming back to try more!

Choose your Pasta!

With so many choices, everyone will love our pasta! Alfredo, meatball, carbonara, and more on our thick penne pasta. Available in Single, Family, and Party sizes. Call us for your catering needs!

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Fresh & Delicious Every Time

Here at The Original PJ's Pizza we use fresh ingredients and provide generations with their favorite meals! Not only can you get delicious hot and fresh food, you can also get a take-and-bake pizza! With customers as our main focus you can get our pizza, your way! Start with one of our specialty pizzas and make it your own or build it from scratch! With us - there's always something new to look forward to! Check back often for specials, new items, seasonal items, great food and more!